Studies, surveys, etc.
-- Oct. 2018 - Martin Lueken, EdChoice’s director of fiscal policy and analysis, makes the case that not only do vouchers save the taxpayer money, they have no effect on per-pupil spending.
When students leave public schools, they usually generate fiscal savings because the voucher amount in all programs is significantly less than the overall cost of educating students in district schools, and typically less than the short-run variable costs.
These savings, however, do not necessarily materialize as reductions in K–12 expenditures because public officials must make decisions to reduce expenditures. When they don’t reduce those expenditures as public schools lose students, public schools will end up with more resources on a per-pupil basis. A common by-product of introducing school choice programs is that spending per student in district schools increases. Although it may be the case that total revenue for a district may drop, it is usually not the case that revenue per student declines.
To read Lueken’s study, go here.
-- June 2018 - United Teachers of Los Angeles President Caputo-Pearl constantly demonizes charters, which he claims suck blood from traditional public schools. But as Reason Foundation scholar Lisa Snell writes, charters account for only 13 percent of the district’s enrollment drop in 2017-2018. She places much of the district’s fiscal woes on its spending on pensions, health care, and special education programs.
The district’s most recent budget of $7.5 billion, approved in June 2017, projected that LAUSD will face a $422-million shortfall by the 2019–2020 school year. In addition, in four years the combination of pension costs, health and welfare costs, and special education costs are projected to take up 57.5% of unrestricted general fund revenue (LAUSD’s main operational funding), before the district spends a single dollar to run a regular school program.
To read more on Snell’s in-depth analysis, go here.
-- February 2018 -A new study out compares the cost-effectiveness of charters and traditional public schools. The findings include:
Education dollars go farther in charter schools than they do traditional public schools.
For every $1,000 in per-pupil funding, students in charter schools earn 17.76 points on the reading portion of the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) compared to 13.42 points for students in traditional public schools. In math, students in the charter sector earn 19.21 NAEP points compared to 14.48 in traditional district schools.
Every dollar spent on students in traditional public schools results in $4.67 in lifetime earnings for those in traditional schools, $6.44 for those in charters, and $5.40 for those who split their K-12 years between both.
To read more about this study, conducted by Patrick J. Wolf of the University of Arkansas, Corey DeAngelis of the Cato Institute, et al, go to https://www.educationdive.com/news/study-compares-cost-effectiveness-of-charters-traditional-public-schools/517101/
-- November 2017 - A Public Policy of California report finds that just 30 percent of all California 9th graders are expected to earn a bachelor’s degree. Also, only 45 percent of the graduating class of 2016 completed college preparatory courses, which are required to be considered for admission to any state school. The report analyzes when students leave the path to college, which students leave, and the major impediments to success.
To learn more, go to http://www.ppic.org/press-release/less-than-a-third-of-states-9th-graders-likely-to-earn-a-bachelors-degree/
-- November 2017 - The yearly EdChoice “Schooling in America” report has been released and, as usual, the pro-choice outfit has done a thorough job of digging into various education crevices. From the executive summary:
The national nomenclature surrounding education has shifted dramatically in the past year. Terms like “vouchers,” “charter schools,” and “tax-credit scholarships”—all educational options—have entered the mainstream dialogue as a result of a political embrace by the executive administration. This emergence has fueled the ongoing debate on what is and should be considered public education in the United States. Often in this political climate, the loudest voices garner the most attention. That has certainly been true in education, where distinct stakeholders of parents, teachers, administrators, boards, and governments often struggle to align their goals. Yet the voices of everyday citizens as a whole also should be examined for this most important public good.
To access the report, go to https://www.edchoice.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/2017-Schooling-In-America-by-Paul-DiPerna-Michael-Shaw-and-Andrew-D-Catt-1.pdf
-- October 2017 - The Independent Institute’s Vicki Alger has released a report on the value of educational savings accounts. She writes that “California is among the bottom five states in the nation in reading and math. Currently, nearly one out of five high school students does not graduate, and just 43 percent of those who do graduate meet California’s four-year college course requirements.”
To read Alger’s in-depth report, go to http://www.independent.org/publications/policy_reports/detail.asp?id=46
-- September 2017 - Using data from the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights, a study released by the Fordham Institute delves into the depths of the teacher absentee problem. On average, teachers miss about eight school days a year due to sick and personal leave, while the average U.S. worker takes only about three-and-a-half sick days per annum. The study shows that 28.3 percent of teachers in traditional public schools are chronically absent, which is defined as missing 11 or more days of school per year due to illness or personal reasons. Interestingly, in charter schools – most of which are not unionized – the corresponding number is just 10.3 percent.
Even within charter schools, the study reveals a glaring disparity. Teachers in unionized charters are almost twice as likely to be chronically absent as their colleagues in non-unionized charters – 17.9 percent to 9.1 percent.
To read this eye-opening report, go here - https://edexcellence.net/publications/teacher-absenteeism
-- September 2017 - When teacher salary schedules first came to be about 100 years ago, they were designed to eliminate discrimination due to race, ethnicity and gender. With such discrimination illegal today, is there really any need for them?
Not according to the Brookings Institution, which has come out with a report that shows the detrimental effects of the step-and-column pay regimen. To read more of this provocative report, go to https://www.brookings.edu/research/scrutinizing-equal-pay-for-equal-work-among-teachers/
-- July 2017 - As Alex Zimmerman writes in Chalkbeat, a recent study finds that” being closer to a charter school led to small increases in math and reading scores, boosts in reported student engagement and school safety, and fewer students being held back a grade.The test score gains increased slightly more in traditional public schools that are co-located with a charter.”
To learn more, go to https://www.chalkbeat.org/posts/ny/2017/07/28/do-charter-schools-hurt-their-neighboring-schools-a-new-study-of-new-york-city-schools-says-no-they-help/
-- May 2017 - Merit pay or “pay for performance” is back in the news, courtesy of a study from Vanderbilt University. The research shows that teacher participation in a merit-pay program led to the equivalent of four extra weeks of student learning, according to an analysis of 44 studies of incentive-pay initiatives in the United States and abroad. In the U.S., the study showed increased student learning equivalent to three additional weeks of schooling.
To learn more about the study, go here - https://my.vanderbilt.edu/matthewspringer/working-papers/
-- May 2017 - University of Arkansas professor and researcher Patrick Wolf has just completed a study in which he found that, “Students in public charter schools receive $5,721 or 29% less in average per-pupil revenue than students in traditional public schools (TPS) in 14 major metropolitan areas across the U. S in Fiscal Year 2014. That is the main conclusion of a study that my research team released today. Of the cities we examined, some have large and well-established charter sectors, like Houston, Los Angeles, New York, and Washington, while others have more emerging charter school sectors like Little Rock, San Antonio, and Tulsa.”
To read more about Wolf’s eye-opening study, go to https://jaypgreene.com/2017/05/10/thats-not-fair/
-- March 2017 - On a “State Report Card” issued by Education Week, California scored below the national average. Massachusetts ranked at the top, followed by New Jersey, Vermont, New Hampshire, Maryland and Connecticut, all earning a B. As a whole, the nation received a C, but the Golden State came in with a solid C-minus, 10th from the bottom among the 50 states and Washington, D.C.
The state ranked 41st in conditions that help children succeed, 39th in school finance, and 30th in achievement. The report card gave the state a D+ in K-12 achievement and school finance, and a C in chance for success.
To see the whole report, go here
-- December 2016 - The Fordham Institute released a report on the difficulty of removing ineffective teachers from public school classrooms. The results of the study showed that in some school districts it is virtually impossible to get rid of an under-performer. The Fordham analysts used a ten point metric based on three simple questions:
- Does tenure protect veteran teachers from performance-based dismissal?
- How long does it take to dismiss an ineffective veteran teacher?
- How vulnerable is an ineffective veteran teacher's dismissal to challenge?
They then used this framework to gauge the difficulty of dismissing ineffective veteran teachers in 25 diverse school districts across the country and found three major obstacles. In 17 of the 25 districts, state law allows teachers to achieve tenure and never relinquish it, even if poor performance reviews follow. Also, it takes forever to cut through the red tape involved in a teacher dismissal. In Los Angeles and San Francisco, it can take five or more years to complete the process. And finally, teachers have multiple appeals to their dismissal in many districts.
To read more about the Fordham Institute report, go to https://edexcellence.net/publications/undue-process
-- December 2016 - The National Council on Teacher Quality released new ratings for 875 undergraduate elementary teacher preparation programs. One of NCTQâ€™s findings is that these programs â€œstill have far to go, particularly in preparing elementary teachers in mathematicsâ€¦. The new findings do little to quell the notion that teaching is an â€˜easy major,â€™ open to anyone who applies in many institutions. Only one quarter of the programs (26 percent) are sufficiently selective, generally admitting only the top half of college goers.â€ To access the NCTQ report, go to http://us1.campaign-archive1.com/?u=c9b11da2ceffae94e1dc196f6&id=5e42db5a3d&e=9dc9a1baf8
-- May 2016 - University of Arkansas professor Patrick Wolf and his team released a meta-analysis of 19 “gold standard” experimental evaluations of the test-score effects of private school choice programs around the world. “The sum of the reliable evidence indicates that, on average, private school choice increases the reading scores of choice users by about 0.27 standard deviations and their math scores by 0.15 standard deviations. These are highly statistically significant, educationally meaningful achievement gains of several months of additional learning from school choice.” To examine the study, go here.
-- January 2016 - The Association of American Educators’ 2016 survey has been released, and, as always, it’s interesting to see where independent-minded teachers come down on education issues. Just a small sampling:
- 69% of teachers would support a blended learning environment in which students spend part of their day with a teacher and part of their day on a computer.
- 67% of those surveyed are interested in negotiating their own contract so that they can negotiate a salary and benefits package that best suits their lifestyle.
- 95% of teachers expressed support for course choice, allowing students to craft custom educational plans utilizing a variety of provider
To access the full survey, go here
-- January 2016 - “The ABCs of School Choice” from the Friedman Foundation is a comprehensive guide to every private school choice program in America. The latest edition defines each of the four types of school choice: education savings accounts, vouchers, tax-credit scholarships, and individual tax credits and deductions. It also features a spread for each school choice program including the most recent participation, funding, and eligibility data as well as information on the program’s rules, regulations and legal history. To access the report, go here.
-- January 2015 - The National Council on Teacher Quality have released the “2015 State Teacher Policy Yearbook.” It is their ninth annual report and is comprised of a National Summary and State-specific reports for all 50 states and the District of Columbia. The 52 volume Yearbook “providesa 360-degree analysis of every state law, rule and regulation that shapes the teaching profession—from teacher preparation, licensing and evaluation to compensation, professional development and dismissal policy.” To view it, go here.
-- January 2015 - According to a recent study by Samuel Abrams, director of the National Center for the Study of Privatization in Education at Columbia University Teachers College, “U.S. primary teachers spend about 12 percent more time leading classes than their OECD counterparts. U.S. lower -- secondary teachers spend about 14 percent more time; and U.S. upper -- secondary teachers spend about 11 percent more time.” To learn more, go here.
-- January 2014 - Teach Plus, whose mission is to “to improve outcomes for urban children by ensuring that a greater proportion of students have access to effective, experienced teachers,” has come out with a survey which finds that teachers are amenable to change the way California does tenure, seniority and dismissals. For more information and access to the survey, go here.
-- January 2014 - According to a 17-year study in New York City, Education Next reports “Minority students who received a school voucher to attend private elementary schools in 1997 were, as of 2013, 10 percent more likely to enroll in college and 35 percent more likely than their peers in public school to obtain a bachelor’s degree.” To read more about the study, go here.
-- December 2014 - NCTQ has released an interesting report on teacher salaries in which it shows where teachers earn the most after adjusting for cost of living. It ranks districts first by the lifetime earnings a teacher accrues in each district over a 30-year career and second by the time it takes teachers to reach the maximum salary benchmark. To see the rankings and learn more, go here.
-- December 2014 - While we all know that the effects of good teachers on children are supremely important, we are also aware that their home lives greatly affect their learning potential. In its Winter 2015 edition, Education Next has an in-depth study on the effects of single-parenthood. To read what the researchers learned, go here.
-- September 2014 – Courtesy of the Fordham Institute, we again learn that there has been a large uptick in the number of non-teaching staff employed in our public schools. To access “The Hidden Half: School Employees Who Don’t Teach,” go here.
-- June 2014 – In a poll, “California voters reject tenure, layoff rules for public school teachers.” To access the survey, go here.
-- June 2014 - The National Council on Teacher Quality has come out with “Roll Call: The importance of teacher attendance,” a study on teacher absenteeism. To view the study, go here.
-- May 2014 - CTEN conducted an internal poll on teachers’ experiences with the Common Core State Standards. To see the results, go here.
-- May 2014 - University of Arkansas researcher Patrick Wolf has come out with an in-depth study, the results of which show that charters are funded at much lower levels than traditional public schools across the country. To download the report, go here. To see the data for California, go here.
-- March 2014 - Cato Institute’s Andrew Coulson has done a telling analysis of education spending in California and its relationship to SAT scores and has found that more money spent does not translate to better results.
-- Feb. 2014 - The Association of American Educators has come out with its 2014 national membership survey. The alternative teachers’ organization posted some very interesting results. For example, the teachers polled came down in favor of various types of parental options:
- 82% of members support public school open enrollment.
- 59% of teachers agree with Wisconsin's Parental Choice Program, allowing low-income students public funds to attend a school of their choice.
- 72% of AAE members support Arizona's Empowerment Scholarship Accounts (ESAs), which enable students to leave their assigned public schools, taking 90% of the state dollars with them. That money, deposited into ESAs, can then be used to access a multitude of education options that better meet their children's needs.
For more on the AAE poll, go to http://www.aaeteachers.org/images/em/2014febnews.pd
-- Jan. 2014 - The National Council on Teacher Quality has a new study which examines “the extent to which America's traditional teacher preparation programs offer future teachers research-based strategies to help them better manage their classroom from the start of their teaching career.
-- August 2013 - Ending Summer Vacation is Long Overdue – Here’s How to Pay for It
-- May 2013 -We
some data that is not typically available at one's fingertips. If you find
anything that you think is erroneous, please let us know.
-- Apr. 2013 - Researcher Greg Forster recently released his
latest study on school choice. A few of the key findings:
empirical studies have examined academic outcomes for school choice
participants using random assignment, the “gold standard” of social
science. Of these, 11 find that choice improves student outcomes—six
that all students benefit and five that some benefit and some are not
affected. One study finds no visible impact. No empirical study has
found a negative impact.
empirical studies (including all methods) have examined school choice’s
impact on academic outcomes in public schools. Of these, 22 find that
choice improves public schools and one finds no visible impact. No
empirical study has found that choice harms public schools.
empirical studies have examined school choice’s fiscal impact on
taxpayers. All six find that school choice saves money for taxpayers.
No empirical study has found a negative fiscal impact.
To read more, go here.
-- March 2013 – CTEN conducted an internal poll on a variety of issues. To see the results, go here.
-- Jan. 2013 - Every year, NCTQ puts out a yearbook, a 52-volume, 9,000-page compendium examining the state of the states on
their policies to promote teacher quality.
-- Oct. 2012 - From the Fordham Institute, in conjunction with Education Reform Now
(an arm of DFER), we now have a state-by-state comparison of teacher
union power. There are several surprises here. For example, the Alabama
(right-to-work state) teachers union is considered more powerful than
the union in non-right-to-work Massachusetts. To watch a brief video
about the study and to read the study itself, go here.
-- Oct. 2012 - On the subject of spending, the Friedman Foundation has come out with
a staggering study which claims that, “America’s K-12 public education
system has experienced tremendous historical growth in employment,
according to the U.S. Department of Education’s National Center for
Education Statistics. Between fiscal year (FY) 1950 and FY 2009, the
number of K-12 public school students in the United States increased by
96 percent while the number of full-time equivalent (FTE) school
employees grew 386 percent. Public schools grew staffing at a rate four
times faster than the increase in students over that time period. Of
those personnel, teachers’ numbers increased 252 percent while
administrators and other staff experienced growth of 702 percent, more
than seven times the increase in students. To read more and download
the study, go here.
-- Sept. 2012 - The always interesting Education Next yearly survey is out. One of the things that makes their polling
different from others is that they will ask a question like, “Do you
think that teachers are paid enough?” Then they will tell those being
polled what teachers make and then repeat the question. Needless to
say, the second response is frequently different than the first one.
To access the survey’s results, go here.
-- Aug. 2012 - The Heritage Foundation’s James Sherk looked at several states to see how many current teachers voted in their union. To see his findings, go here.
-- July 2012 - According to a report released by the Education Action Group, the
teachers’ contract in Los Angeles is costing the city, which is on the
verge of bankruptcy, unnecessary millions that it can ill afford to
spend at this time. “Sucking the Life Out of America’s Public Schools”
gives us the gory details. To read the report, go here.
-- May 2012 - Professor Jay Greene claims that “Charter Benefits Are Proven by the Best Evidence”
and that “opponents of charter schools have no equally rigorous
evidence on their side.
-- Mar. 2012 - A report by the non-partisan Legislative Analyst Office tackles the
teacher layoff process in California. March Reduction In Force notices,
seniority, bureaucratic bloat, etc. are all dealt with in a fair and
unbiased way. To read the report, go here.
-- Nov. 2011 - In North Carolina, the results of a study were released which show
that giving public school students a choice as to which public school
they can go to dramatically lowers the crime rate. Interestingly, the
choices in this study are limited to traditional public schools – no
charters schools or vouchers are involved. To read more, go here.
-- Nov. 2011 - A couple of researchers
at the Heritage Foundation suggest that teachers are paid too
much. To read the report, go here. The authors of the study
summarized their findings in a Wall Street Journal op-ed.
-- Oct. 2011 - Jay Greene and Josh McGee have developed a database which enables
anyone to learn how their school district shapes up next to not only
others in their state and country, but to other countries also. To
learn more and explore The Global Report Card, go here (http://globalreportcard.org/)
-- Aug. 2011 - A new study from the
National Center for Education Information deals with reform,
union issues, etc.
-- May 2011 – CTEN conducted an internal poll on a variety of issues. To see the results, go here.
-- May 2011 - Four day work week for schools? May be worth a
try. For more, go here
-- Apr. 2011 - A Harvard Study Shows that Lecture-Style Presentations Lead to Higher Student
-- Jan. 2011 - In a time when student testing has gotten a very bad name, a new
study has emerged which shows that testing actually helps students
learn. The study claims that testing and a reading theory
developed in 1946 remain great learning tools. To read more, go here.
-- Dec. 2010 - Seniority is examined in a study by the Center for Education Data and
Research at the University of Washington. Dan Goldhaber, lead author of
the study and the center's director "projected that student achievement
after seniority-based layoffs would drop by an estimated 2.5 to 3.5
months of learning per student, when compared to laying off the least
effective teachers." Goldhaber then added, "If your bottom line is
student achievement, then this is not the best system," To read more, go here. To access the study, go here.
-- Nov. 2010 -
"Percentage of U.S. Students Achieving at Advanced Levels in Math
Trails Most Industrialized Nations.” This in-depth study,
sponsored by Education Next, is very troubling. It asserts that "New
analysis finds U.S. ranked 31st out of 56 countries in the percentage
of students performing at a high level of accomplishment, trailing
Korea, Canada, the Czech Republic, Slovak Republic, Poland and
Lithuania, among others." For more information, the press release and a
link to the study can be found here.
-- Feb. 2010 - The National Council on Teacher Quality has published a report
about seniority and layoffs called Teacher
Layoffs: Rethinking "Last-Hired, First-Fired" Policies.
-- Jan. 2010 - Andrew Coulson has written an exceptional article in which he
contends that the unions effects on collective bargaining are trivial.
He claims that their key success has been their effective lobbying to
maintain the educational status quo. To read this provocative article, go here.
-- Nov. 2009 - In a recent study, researcher Michael Lovenheim found that
"...unionization had no discernible effects on average teacher pay or
per-student district expenditures in Iowa , Minnesota or Indiana from
1972 to 1991." To read more about this study, cited in the Nov. 30,
2009 NCTQ Bulletin, please go here.
-- Oct. 2009 - The Destruction of a
Profession is a must read for anyone who has an interest in public
education. This blog post references a new study, Teaching for a
Living: How Teachers See the Profession Today , which claims that 40%
of public school teachers are "disheartened." To read the full report,
please go here.
-- Oct. 2009 - In a RAND Corporation
study , conducted in New York City , we learn that ending social
promotion is indeed beneficial for students. The various self-esteem
counterarguments are debunked.
-- Sept. 2009 - Caroline Hoxby's important study "How New York City's Charter Schools
Affect Achievement" can be accessed here. At the same time, she released a
paper on the CREDO study. "A recent study of charter schools' effect on
student achievement has been published by CREDO (2009). It contains a
statistical mistake that causes a biased estimate of how charter
schools affect achievement. This paper explains that mistake." To read
the memo, go here.
-- May 2009 - If you are seeking an alternative to teaching in a public school,
private school may suit you. Research says you may find greater
satisfaction there. Please read this study from the Friedman Foundation.
-- Jan. 2009 - Harvard researcher Thomas Kane authored a "groundbreaking study that
suggests charter school students in Boston outperform their peers at
other public schools in Boston. Results for pilot schools were less
clear; some analyses showed positive results at the elementary and high
school level, while results for middle school students were less
encouraging. The study uses an innovative research design based on
school lotteries that allowed for a direct comparison of charter and
pilot school students with their peers." To learn more, go here.